MAC Midweek Props: Kelly, Gleason Highlight Top Picks

  • Kiael Kelly’s dual-threat profile suggests he’ll hit the over on 160.5 passing yards, while Jordan Rubin’s low rushing average supports the under on 62.5 rushing yards.
  • Tucker Gleason’s recent string of strong passing performances makes the over on 229.5 passing yards appealing, whereas DeAree Rogers’ inconsistency in recent games supports the under on 52.5 receiving yards.

MUNCIE, Ind. - Two midweek Mid-American Conference matchups offer sharp betting opportunities for prop bettors Wednesday night as Ball State hosts Kent State and Toledo welcomes Northern Illinois.

Cardinals and Golden Flashes Best Prop Bets

  • Kiael Kelley – Total Passing Yards: Over 160.5 -115
  • Jordan Rubin – Total Rushing Yards: Under 62.5 -115

Kiael Kelly, the quarterback for Ball State, makes a strong argument for the over on total passing yards at 160.5 yards with -115 odds. In five of the eight games this season, the Cardinals signal-caller has exceeded this threshold; in one other game, he was only ten yards short.

Kelly, who averages 122.75 passing yards and 52.125 rushing yards per game, stands out for his flexibility. His total yardage regularly exceeds the 160.5 mark thanks to his dual-threat skills. His ability to generate offense through many channels has drawn attention from Indiana CFB sites.

Kent State running back Jordan Rubin offers a contrasting opportunity on the under at 62.5 rushing yards for -115 odds. Only once in four games this season has Rubin surpassed this threshold, recording a 25% success percentage. At 49 yards per game on average this season, he is far below the set mark.

Rockets and Huskies Best Prop Bets

  • Tucker Gleason – Total Passing Yards: Over 229.5 -115
  • DeAree Rogers – Total Receiving Yards: Under 52.5 -115

Toledo quarterback Tucker Gleason enters Wednesday's contest riding momentum, making the over at 229.5 passing yards for -115 odds an attractive option. Gleason has surpassed this mark in five of eight games this season.

More importantly, Gleason has cleared 229.5 yards in each of his last four outings, averaging 258.25 yards during that stretch. Ohio CFB props reflect his recent form against a Northern Illinois secondary that has struggled with consistency.

Northern Illinois receiver DeAree Rogers presents an under opportunity at 52.5 receiving yards for -115 odds according to Illinois sportsbooks. With just one performance above the line in his last five games, Rogers has only surpassed this threshold in three out of eight games.

College football prop sites show his stronger statistics came early in the season, suggesting a downward trend as defenses have adjusted. Outside of his season high 107 yards against Ohio a couple games back, most of his production occurred during the Huskies' first three games before opponents began limiting his impact.

About Hunter Gold

Hunter is a college football enthusiast who's been on the CollegeFootballProps.com team since 2025. He grew up a Florida State fan and just recently graduated as a Nole earlier in 2025. When he's not analyzing the latest Seminoles matchups, he's following up on the top college stars and picking up a game of College Football 25.